Dr. Nyan Case On Hold?

By Yassah J. Wright

Supreme Court has reserved ruling in the government’s appeal, which challenged a lower court decision in favor of former National Public Health Institute of Liberia (NPHIL) Director General, Dr. Dougbeh Christopher Nyan.

The withheld ruling came about following a hearing in which justices questioned the extent of presidential removal powers, and the statutory protections governing Dr. Nyan’s tenure.

Associate Justices Question government’s reliance on constitutional authority amid dispute over NPHIL Act and due process.

During Tuesday’s hearing, government lawyers sought to waive their oral arguments; a point that prompted Chief Justice Yamie Quiqui Gbeisay to question whether the request amounted to a withdrawal of the government’s appeal.

The lawyer clarified that the government was not withdrawing the appeal, but believed its existing submissions sufficiently explained the legal basis for Dr. Nyan’s removal.

Counselor Tiawan Saye Gongloe, who represented Dr. Nyan, criticized the government’s position.

Gongloe argued that it was a waste of the court’s time for the government to waive oral arguments after bringing the matter before the Supreme Court. He urged the justices to take note of the government’s decision, and proceed accordingly.

Justices Question Presidential Authority

Associate Justice Yussif D. Kaba pressed the government’s lawyer on the meaning of statutory tenure, and whether the President’s constitutional authority to appoint, and remove public officials overrides protections established under the NPHIL Act?

In response, the government’s lawyer maintained that the constitution is the supreme law of the land, and takes precedence over the NPHIL Act in matters concerning presidential appointment, and removal powers.

The government also argued that NPHIL’s Board of Directors had recommended Dr. Nyan’s removal through a resolution dated September 12, 2025, and that President Joseph Nyuma Boakai acted on the board’s recommendation.

Justice Kaba, however, asked the government to identify the specific provision of the 2016 NPHIL Act authorizing the President to remove the director general.

In referenced to Section 4.4 of the Act, Kaba highlighted provisions outlining grounds for removal, including gross inefficiency, corruption, conviction of a crime, and conduct contrary to the public interest, or the principles of good governance.

The provision also requires that removal procedures comply with due process, and applicable law.

The questions raised during the hearing placed the statutory conditions for removing Dr. Nyan at the center of the dispute, particularly whether the government followed the legal procedures required before terminating Dr. Nyan’s tenure.

Defense Challenges Due Process

Associate Justice Kanneh subsequently asked Dr. Nyan’s lawyer whether the Board of Directors’ recommendation to the President could be considered due process?

Gongloe rejected that position, insisting that his client was neither notified of the allegations, or grounds for his removal nor given an opportunity to respond before the decision was made.

The defense maintained that a board resolution recommending removal does not, by itself, establish that the affected official was afforded the procedural protections required by law.

The issue of due process remains central to the case, as the Court considers the relationship between the President’s constitutional powers, and the statutory safeguards governing the leadership of NPHIL.

Background to the Dispute

Dr. Nyan was dismissed on October 15, 2025, before completing his five-year statutory tenure as NPHIL Director General. He challenged the decision, when he argued that his removal violated the law.

On February 16, 2026, Associate Justice Jamesetta Howard Wolokolie, ruled in Dr. Nyan’s favor, finding that the government had failed to establish sufficient grounds for his removal.

The ruling ordered his reinstatement, or compensation for the remainder of his statutory tenure.

The government subsequently appealed the decision to the Full Bench, seeking a reversal of the lower court’s ruling.

With the Supreme Court now reserving ruling, the dispute remains unresolved.

Comments are closed.